Colton managed to piss off Jeff big time. I don't think I have ever seen Jeff that angry.
No kidding! I am sure that there was at least one other Survivor and loved one who would have wanted to play the game again. But Colton took those places because he "wanted" and they wanted to give him a chance at redemption. Did I understand correctly that Jeff had accused him of faking being sick in One World when he had to be medic-vaced due to some stomach issue? If so, I would have never have let him play again! It is one thing to quit the game but it is a totally different thing to fake being sick to get out of the game and causing his tribe-mates to worry about him (though I don't remember him ever expressing his desire to leave-he seemed to enjoy playing the game too much).